Skip to main content
The problem with forgiveness | In-person
TalksFree

The problem with forgiveness | In-person

Ask AI: is it for me?

Similar events

View all

Not quite it? Try these

See all

About This Event

The event will focus on understanding the nature and ethics of forgiveness as part of a partnership between the Royal Society of Edinburgh and The Royal Institute of Philosophy.

The RSE's 2026 partnership event with The Royal Institute of Philosophy will focus on understanding the nature and the ethics of forgiveness

Forgiveness can be psychologically and emotionally hard - sometimes it can feel almost impossible. But forgiveness also raises some surprisingly tricky philosophical questions.

Forgiving involves letting go of blame and the hostile feelings that come with it, while still believing that the person was at fault. But this makes forgiveness seem paradoxical: If someone is blameworthy for a wrong, it is rational to blame them. And if they aren’t, what is there to forgive?

And, while forgiveness is something that we can try to earn, it’s not something we can demand. Sincere repentance and making amends may give us good reasons to forgive, but the act of forgiving is often seen as a choice – something we can do freely even when the wrongdoer hasn’t shown any remorse. But, is it right to forgive someone who hasn’t apologised or owned up to what they’ve done? And is it right not to forgive someone who has?

In this talk, Professor Maria Alvarez explores what forgiveness really means, whether it can be owed to another, and whether it can be right to forgive unrepentant wrongdoers.

The event will include a panel of experts who, alongside Maria and the event Chair, will discuss the subject further before opening the Q&A to the Audience.

Speaker: Professor Maria Alvarez

Professor of Philosophy, King's College London

Maria Alvarez is a Professor of Philosophy at King’s College London. Before joining King’s, she was a lecturer at the University of Southampton, having previously taught at the Universities of Oxford and Reading.

Her philosophical interests ranges over questions about human agency, moral responsibility, freedom, reasons, and ethics. She has published on those topics in journals and collections and her book Kinds of Reasons: An Essay in the Philosophy of Action was published by Oxford University Press in 2010. She is currently working on the relationship between agency, choice and moral responsibility.

She is co-Editor of Philosophy, the journal of the Royal Institute of Philosophy.

PANELLIST: Professor Matthew Chrisman FRSE

Professor of Ethics and Epistemology, University of Edinburgh

Matthew is a professor of philosophy at the University of Edinburgh, where my teaching and research have focused on ethics, epistemology, language and politics. He is principally interested in using the language of norms and values to discuss how to live and what to believe. He also maintains a keen interest in the history of philosophical answers to these questions, as well as the contemporary social/political role of the various linguistic manifestations of disagreement, debate, discussion, and protest. He has published several monographs and textbooks on these topics, as well as many articles, teaching resources, and pieces in the popular media. He was a member of the Young Academy of Scotland and is a founding director of the Centre for Responsible Debate.

PANELLIST: Dr Louise Kennefick

Senior Lecturer in Criminal Law, University of Glasgow

Louise Kennefick is a Senior Lecturer in Criminal Law at the University of Glasgow. A qualified solicitor in England and Wales, she completed her PhD on criminal responsibility at University College Cork in 2011. Her research spans criminal law theory, criminal justice and criminology, with a particular focus on blame, condemnation and criminal responsibility. She also examines community supervision and probation through qualitative, stakeholder-centred research. Louise has received funding and awards from the Royal Society of Edinburgh, the Society of Legal Scholars, the Irish Research Council, the European COST Network and the Irish Department of Justice. Her monograph, The Boundaries of Blame: Towards a Universal Partial Defence for the Criminal Law, was published by Cambridge University Press in 2025.

CHAIR: Professor John Gillies OBE FRCGP FRCPE FRSE

Honorary Professor of General Practice, Usher Institute, University of Edinburgh

John is an Edinburgh medical graduate. He worked in Malawi, then as a rural GP, educator and academic in Scotland. After completing an MA in Ethics & Law, I served on the RCGP Ethics Committee for 4 years. He was Chair of RCGP (Scotland) and published on rural health and health policy. He is a co-director of the Global Compassion and Empathy Initiative (GCEI) of the University of Edinburgh. This year, he partnered with the Empathy Place, based at the Edinburgh Veterinary School, on a successful Compassion and Empathy in One Health conference.

Important points to note

This event is suitable for ages 16+

Sensitive content - Please note that this event will include discussion of forgiveness, which implies discussing wrongdoing, and illustrations with examples that may be distressing or controversial. Also, the issues may resonate with people’s experiences in ways that are painful.

Privacy policy: Please note that

Description supplied by the event organiser.

Staying overnight?

Hotels within walking distance of The Royal Society Of Edinburgh.

Searching near 22-26 George Street, Edinburgh, EH2 2PQ
Check-in: Wednesday, 9 December 2026
Find hotels near this venuecompare prices →

Ad · Stay22 affiliate link

Similar Events in Edinburgh

View all →

More at The Royal Society Of Edinburgh

View all →

Frequently asked questions

The problem with forgiveness | In-person takes place on Wednesday, 9 December 2026 at 18:00.

The problem with forgiveness | In-person is held at The Royal Society Of Edinburgh in Edinburgh (22-26 George Street, Edinburgh, EH2 2PQ).

Entry to The problem with forgiveness | In-person is free.

Yes — hotels within walking distance of The Royal Society Of Edinburgh can be compared using the accommodation search further down this page.

Tickets for The problem with forgiveness | In-person can be booked via Eventbrite using the "Check Tickets & Live Prices" button on this page, which opens the official booking site in a new tab.

Price

Free Entry

Get Tickets